MTG Formats
A format whose legality rule is a price tag. Every card at two cents or less on Magic Online is legal, the list is redrawn every season, and any deck that gets popular prices itself out of existence.
Penny Dreadful is a community-run Magic Online format with one legality rule: a card is legal if it costs 0.02 tickets or less. Everything else is ordinary constructed Magic, at 60 cards, four copies and 20 life.
Around fifteen thousand cards clear that bar in a given season, across every rarity. Commons and uncommons make up most of it, but plenty of rares and even mythics are in there: a card is cheap because nobody is playing it, not because of where it sat in the pack.
Every other format decides what is legal by asking when a card was printed or what colour its rarity symbol is. Penny Dreadful asks what it is worth, which is the only rule that updates itself.
the constraint that makes the format work
The format runs its own leagues and tournaments through the community site that maintains it, so there is a live metagame and a published legal list each season rather than an honour system.
About a week after each new Standard-legal set arrives on Magic Online, prices are checked again and a new season starts. With several sets a year, that means the format resets roughly quarterly.
Season starts. A forgotten rare from an old set is worth a cent, so it is legal.
Someone builds a deck around it and puts up results. Other players buy copies, and the price climbs above two cents.
The next set releases, the season rolls over, and the card is checked again. It is now too expensive, so it rotates out and the deck built around it stops existing.
A few seasons later, nobody is playing it, the price has fallen back under two cents, and it is legal again.
That cycle is not a bug being tolerated, it is the point. The format's metagame refreshes itself without anyone having to decide anything, and a deck that becomes dominant is dismantled by the same players who made it dominant.
Most formats need a banned list because a broken card stays broken until somebody removes it. Penny Dreadful does not, because a broken card cannot stay cheap. Demand raises the price, the price crosses two cents, and the next season removes it automatically.
A format of two-cent cards must be full of unplayable rubbish.
It is full of cards nobody currently wants, which is a very different thing. Sets rotate, strategies fall out of fashion, and perfectly functional cards drop to nothing. A Penny Dreadful season contains real removal, real card draw and real threats, most of which were Standard playables a few years ago.
Start from the season's legal list, not from memory. The card you want may have been legal last season and not this one. Every deckbuilding decision in this format begins by checking the current list.
Expect the format to be slower than Pauper or Modern. Cheap cards are cheap because nobody plays them, which usually means the most efficient rates are missing. Games go longer, so card advantage and resilient threats matter more than raw speed.
Two colours, 23 to 25 lands. Fixing at this price point is workable but not free, and the mana bases are built from the same tapped lands every budget format leans on.
Do not fall in love with a deck. Whatever you build has a shelf life measured in months, by design. Treat each season as its own puzzle and the rotation stops being a loss.
Both are budget formats and they are not substitutes for each other. Pauper's rule is rarity, so it is stable across years, playable in paper, and includes the strongest commons ever printed, which makes it genuinely fast and powerful. Penny Dreadful's rule is price, so it changes every season, exists only on Magic Online, and has a wider but weaker pool.
If you want a cheap deck to own permanently and take to a store, that is Pauper. If you want a new puzzle every few months for the price of a coffee, this is the one. The format comparison puts both next to everything else.
Penny Dreadful: a community-run Magic Online format where a card is legal if it costs 0.02 tickets or less. Around fifteen thousand cards qualify, at every rarity, and the whole legal list is redrawn each season. Deck construction is the usual 60-card minimum, four copies, fifteen-card sideboard, 20 life.
A new season begins about a week after each new Standard-legal set arrives, at which point every card's price is checked again. Cards that have risen above two cents rotate out; cards that have fallen back below it become legal again. Since Magic sets arrive several times a year, the format resets roughly quarterly.
Effectively not, and the rotation is why. If a deck becomes popular enough to matter, people buy its cards, those cards get more expensive, and they price themselves out of the format at the next season change. The market does the banning, which is the format's entire design in one sentence.
A couple of tickets, often less. No individual card can cost more than two cents by definition, so a full 75 costs about what a single common costs in a paper eternal format. The cost of entry is really a Magic Online account rather than the deck.
Not in any official sense. The format is defined by Magic Online ticket prices, so it only exists where those prices do. Nothing stops a playgroup agreeing to a season's legal list in paper, but there is no sanctioned paper or Arena version, and the closest widely-played budget alternative in paper is Pauper.
TurnZero HQ tracks decks and win rates whatever they cost, so a two-ticket brew gets the same record as a real one.
Create Free Account