Build Commander
How Much Protection Should You Run in Commander?
2 to 4 pieces of protection is enough for most decks. A plan that depends on one card resolving needs a way to keep that card alive once it does.
The starting number
2 to 4 pieces of protection covers most decks, split between board-wide effects for the turn you're about to get wiped and single-target effects for the turn your best card is about to get removed. That's on top of, not instead of, the removal covered in the deck template.
Protection is the category players most often forget to build in on purpose. It's easy to load a deck with threats and interaction and never ask what happens the moment somebody points a removal spell at the one card the whole plan depends on. A hexproof effect held up at the right time is often worth more than another copy of the threat it's protecting.
What actually moves the number
A deck built around one card wants more. Voltron decks, a commander-dependent combo, or any plan that collapses the instant its key piece is answered should treat protection as close to mandatory, not a nice-to-have. See the Voltron archetype guide for how heavily those decks lean on it.
A go-wide deck can run less, or spread it differently. When your threat is the whole board rather than one card, a board wipe is the bigger danger than targeted removal, so protection here should skew toward effects like Heroic Intervention that protect everything at once rather than single-target hexproof.
Instant speed matters more here than almost anywhere else in the deck. A protection spell that only works at sorcery speed can't respond to a removal spell already on the stack, which is exactly the moment it's needed. Weight this category toward instants.
Don't double up on the same failure mode. Four single-target hexproof spells all solve "my commander got targeted" and do nothing the turn a wipe resets the board. A small, varied set covers more of what can actually go wrong than a large, repetitive one.
Protection worth knowing
Two shapes: an equipment that protects whatever it's attached to every turn, and an instant that protects one thing for one crucial moment.
Heroic Intervention ↗
Two mana, your whole board gets hexproof and indestructible until end of turn. The single best rate on board-wide protection in the format.
Swiftfoot Boots ↗
Cheap to cast, cheap to move, hexproof and haste on whatever it's attached to. Slower than a spell since it has to resolve and then be equipped, but it protects every turn after that.
Lightning Greaves ↗
Free to equip, haste and shroud on the creature wearing it. Shroud cuts both ways, it also stops you targeting your own equipped creature with a helpful spell.
Tamiyo's Safekeeping ↗
One mana, hexproof and indestructible on any one permanent, and it gains you a little life on top. The cheapest single-target answer to a removal spell aimed at your best card.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much protection should a Commander deck run?
2 to 4 pieces is enough for most decks: a couple of ways to protect your board from a wipe, and a couple of ways to protect one key card from targeted removal. A deck whose whole plan rides on one card (a Voltron commander, a combo piece) wants toward the higher end of that range or above it.
Is protection the same as removal?
No, they're opposite tools. Removal answers a threat someone else controls; protection keeps one of your own permanents safe from an opponent's removal, a board wipe, or a bad combat. Both count as interaction, but they solve different problems and neither substitutes for the other.
What's the difference between hexproof and shroud for protection purposes?
Hexproof stops your opponents from targeting the permanent; shroud stops everyone, including you. A card like Lightning Greaves' shroud is genuinely worse for a deck that wants to target its own equipped creature with buffs or protection spells later, which is why hexproof effects (Swiftfoot Boots, Heroic Intervention) are usually the safer default.
Do I need protection if I already run a lot of removal?
Usually yes, since they cover different failure modes. Removal keeps the table's threats in check; protection is what keeps your own plan alive once you've already committed to it. A deck stacked with removal and nothing to protect its own board is still one well-timed wipe away from losing everything it built.
See how often protection actually saved your game.
TurnZero HQ's game recaps log the swings that mattered, so you can tell whether that hexproof spell earned its slot.
Create Free Account