Card Guides
Smothering Tithe costs $52.35 for its cheapest copy and is a Game Changer, so Bracket 1 and 2 decks can't play it at all. Here are 10 cards that do part of its job, with what each gives up, what it costs and how often the 1,495 decks tracked in TurnZero HQ run it.
Prices, deck counts and the Game Changers list checked on November 15, 2026.
Smothering Tithe is a four-mana white enchantment: whenever an opponent draws a card, that player may pay {2}. If they don't, you create a Treasure. Every opponent draws at least once a turn, so at a table that rarely pays it makes several Treasure a round, and it taxes the table's draw spells at the same time.
No card does both halves at its price. The cards below split it up: one makes Treasure off opponents' spells, four put lands onto the battlefield when the table ramps faster than you, two find lands so you hit every land drop, and three make Treasure off your own plan in other colors. Smothering Tithe is in 42 of the 1,495 decks tracked in TurnZero HQ, and one alternative here is run more often than it is: Black Market Connections.
Prices are the cheapest paper copy of each card in any printing or finish, TCGplayer market prices via Scryfall, November 15, 2026. Card links go through our TCGplayer affiliate link; see our affiliate disclosure.
Monologue Tax is the only white card here that makes Treasure off what opponents do. The rest pay you in lands whenever an opponent has more lands than you, which is the situation Smothering Tithe usually fixes in a real game.
| Card | What changes |
|---|---|
| Monologue Tax $1.86 | The closest swap. It makes the same Treasure, but when an opponent casts their second spell in a turn rather than whenever they draw, so it triggers less at a slow table. Nobody can pay to stop it, and it costs three mana instead of four. |
| Archaeomancer's Map $0.98 | Puts two basic Plains in your hand when it enters. After that, whenever an opponent's land enters and that player has more lands than you, you may put a land from your hand onto the battlefield. Lands stay where Treasure is spent once, but it stops working once you catch up. |
| Land Tax $16.31 | One mana. Each upkeep that an opponent has more lands than you, it puts up to three basic lands into your hand. That is card advantage more than ramp, since you still play one land a turn, so it is strongest beside a way to put extra lands down. |
| Keeper of the Accord $0.46 | Checks each opponent at their end step: a basic Plains onto the battlefield tapped if that player has more lands than you, and a 1/1 Soldier if they have more creatures. It can trigger for every opponent who is ahead, every turn. |
| Deep Gnome Terramancer $8.51 | Two mana, with flash. Once each turn, when lands enter under an opponent's control without being played (a ramp spell or a fetchland, for example), you may put a Plains card onto the battlefield tapped. Any Plains card, so it can fetch a dual land with the Plains type. |
| Knight of the White Orchid $0.93 | A one-time catch-up on a body. If an opponent has more lands than you when it enters, you may put a Plains card onto the battlefield untapped. It has first strike and costs {W}{W}. |
| Weathered Wayfarer $1.66 | One mana. Pay {W} and tap it to put any land card into your hand, utility lands included, but only while an opponent has more lands than you. Like Land Tax, it finds lands rather than playing them. |
Outside white, nothing taxes opponents' draws, so these make Treasure off your own game plan instead: attacking, sacrificing creatures, or paying life.
| Card | What changes |
|---|---|
| Professional Face-Breaker $1.53 | Red. Makes a Treasure whenever one or more of your creatures deal combat damage to a player, and you can sacrifice a Treasure to exile the top card of your library and play it that turn. Best in a deck that attacks every turn. |
| Pitiless Plunderer $3.15 | Black. Makes a Treasure whenever another creature you control dies, so it is ramp for a sacrifice deck rather than a tax on the table. |
| Black Market Connections $14.14 | Black. In your first main phase you can take a Treasure for 1 life, and also a card for 2 or a 3/2 changeling for 3. Every mode is your choice, so it never depends on what opponents do, and it can cost a lot of life. |
3 of the 10 cost under a dollar and 7 cost under $5. The most expensive, Land Tax, is still 31% of Smothering Tithe's price. Ordered by how many tracked decks run each:
| Card | Color | Price | Decks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smothering Tithe (Game Changer) | $52.35 | 42 | |
| Black Market Connections | $14.14 | 56 | |
| Pitiless Plunderer | $3.15 | 25 | |
| Archaeomancer's Map | $0.98 | 22 | |
| Monologue Tax | $1.86 | 20 | |
| Professional Face-Breaker | $1.53 | 20 | |
| Land Tax | $16.31 | 19 | |
| Knight of the White Orchid | $0.93 | 14 | |
| Keeper of the Accord | $0.46 | 6 | |
| Weathered Wayfarer | $1.66 | 6 | |
| Deep Gnome Terramancer | $8.51 | 0 |
TurnZero HQ deck stats, November 15, 2026: how many of the 1,495 decks built in TurnZero HQ include each card in their 99. A deck can run several of these, so the counts are not head-to-head choices. Prices are TCGplayer market prices via Scryfall, the cheapest paper printing in any finish, and move daily.
Not sure your deck needs more ramp at all? How much ramp to run has the counts, and the best ramp in Commander covers the mana rocks and land spells most decks start with. If your deck is losing Smothering Tithe to fit a bracket, the full Game Changers list shows what else counts, and Rhystic Study alternatives does the same job for the other tax-or-else enchantment.
Monologue Tax, at $1.86 for its cheapest copy on November 15, 2026. It is the only other white card here that makes Treasure off what opponents do, though it needs them to cast two spells in a turn. If your table usually out-ramps you, Archaeomancer's Map ($0.98) keeps your land count level instead.
Yes. It is on Wizards of the Coast's Game Changers list as of November 15, 2026, so Bracket 1 and 2 decks can't play it and a Bracket 3 deck can play it as one of its three. None of the ten cards on this page is on the list.
No, not as of November 15, 2026. It is legal in every bracket. At $16.31 it costs more than most cards on this page, but less than a third of Smothering Tithe.
Yes. It triggers whenever an opponent draws a card, including the card they draw for the turn, and once for each card. When a player draws several cards at once, they draw them all before deciding how many of the triggers to pay {2} for.
Only if your deck has a reason: it needs to fit Bracket 1 or 2, it has three better Game Changers, or you would rather spend the money elsewhere. In a white deck that can afford it, it is still one of the strongest mana engines in the format, especially at a table that plays a lot of draw spells.
Build or import your deck in TurnZero HQ and the Deck Lab shows its price and its bracket as you swap cards, then tracks how it does once you play it.
Create Free Account