Roundups
Best Commanders for Beginners
The best first commander is simple to pilot, forgiving on mana, and has a game plan you can explain in one sentence, not the strongest card you can find. Here are eight real commanders across different colors and strategies that meet that bar, each with the specific reason it works for a first deck.
What makes a commander beginner-friendly
Forgiving mana comes first. Fewer colors means fewer manabase headaches, and a mono-color deck never has to think about fixing at all. A two-color deck like is still a short, easy manabase to build; every color you add past that is a real deckbuilding cost, not just a flavor choice.
A good first commander's plan also fits in one sentence: make tokens and attack, sacrifice small things and bring back a big one, exile a card and maybe play it. If you can't explain what your deck is trying to do in a breath, it's a harder deck to pilot well, whatever its power level.
It should also stay off the rest of the table's radar early on. A commander that looks terrifying the moment it hits the battlefield draws removal turn two, which is a frustrating first few games for a new player who hasn't built up a feel for when to hold cards back. And ideally it's a commander you can buy into rather than assemble card by card, whether that's an actual Commander precon or a widely available, cheap staple list, so your first deck is a purchase rather than a weeks-long shopping project.
Eight commanders worth starting with
Krenko, Mob Boss ↗
Mono-red, one color, one plan: tap Krenko, get more Goblins than you had a second ago, attack with all of them. There's no combat trick to memorize and no stack interaction to track on your own turn.
Trostani, Selesnya's Voice ↗
Two colors, both good at the same thing: making creatures and keeping your life total high. Every token you make gains you life the moment it enters, so the deck is naturally forgiving of a slow start or a rough combat.
Meren of Clan Nel Toth ↗
Teaches the graveyard-recursion mechanic as cleanly as any commander in the format: sacrifice something small, get an experience counter, bring a bigger creature back at end of turn. The loop repeats itself, so the deck plays the same way every game.
Edgar Markov ↗
Three colors, but the plan is a single sentence: attack with Vampires, make more Vampires. Every attack grows your whole board at once, which makes combat math easy to read even before you've played many games.
Ghired, Conclave Exile ↗
Enters and immediately hands you a 4/4, then copies your best token every time you attack. The whole deck answers one question, make a big creature token and copy it, which is an easy plan to hold in your head across a long game.
Prosper, Tome-Bound ↗
Exiles the top card of your library every end step and lets you play it, which is a genuinely satisfying value engine with a rule simple enough to explain in one breath: look at a free card, maybe play it, get a Treasure if you do.
Isshin, Two Heavens as One ↗
A three-mana static ability with no activation to remember: your triggers just happen twice when you attack. It rewards the most basic action in the game, attacking, which makes it forgiving for a player still learning when to hold back.
Rin and Seri, Inseparable ↗
Cats and Dogs go wide off cheap creature spells, and the theme does half the deckbuilding for you. Casting either type makes the other, so the board grows on its own and the deck is cheap to assemble a first version of.
What to avoid for a first deck
Five-color piles look exciting on the shelf but hand a new player the hardest manabase in the game before they've played a single land drop with intention. Save for later, once you already know what a good manabase feels like.
Skip anything whose entire plan is a two-card combo. Those decks either do nothing until both pieces are in play, which reads as a broken deck for the first ten turns of every game, or they end the game the instant the pieces connect, which is not a fun way to learn how a normal Commander turn plays out.
And be wary of a decklist built around one specific expensive card. If the whole plan collapses without a $60 staple you don't own yet, you don't have a deck yet either. Every commander on this list works with cheap, widely available cards from turn one.
From precon to your own deck
Any of these eight is a fine deck to play unmodified for your first several games. Once you've got a feel for how it wins and where it stumbles, the natural next step is tuning it, and that starts with understanding what a well-built Commander deck's card counts actually look like. See the Commander deck template for the target numbers, and mana colors and the color pie if you're ready to reason about why each color does what it does rather than just following a list.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best commander for a beginner?
There's no single answer, because the right one depends on what kind of game you want to play. What every good first pick shares is a plan you can state in one sentence (make tokens and attack, sacrifice things and bring back a bigger one), a forgiving mana base, and a low enough profile that the rest of the table doesn't feel like it has to remove your commander on sight. Krenko, Mob Boss and Meren of Clan Nel Toth are two very different decks that both meet that bar.
How many colors should a first Commander deck have?
One or two. A mono-color deck never has to think about its manabase at all, and a two-color deck is still a short, forgiving mana base to build. Three colors is playable and several strong beginner commanders (Edgar Markov, Ghired, Rin and Seri) are three-color, but every extra color adds real mana-fixing cards you have to buy and build around, which is a deckbuilding lesson worth saving for your second or third deck rather than your first.
Do I need to buy a precon, or can I build from scratch?
Either works, but a precon is the faster path for most new players. Most of the commanders here have shipped in an official Commander precon at some point, which means someone else already solved the manabase and the card count and you can be playing the same evening you buy it. Building from scratch is completely fine too, it just means budgeting more time before your first game rather than after it.
Should a beginner copy a strong decklist from the internet?
Copying a well-built list will win you more games faster than building alone, but it also means you didn't make any of the decisions in it, so the first time a card underperforms you won't know why. A middle path works well: start from a precon or a simple published list, then swap a card or two in over your first several games and watch what changes.
Is a mono-color commander always easier than a two-color one?
Usually simpler on the mana side, since there's only one land type to worry about, but not automatically a simpler deck to play. Krenko, Mob Boss is mono-red and extremely straightforward; some mono-color commanders build toward complicated combo lines instead. Color count tells you about manabase difficulty, not about how simple the deck's game plan is, so check both before deciding.
However you build your first deck, track how it actually plays.
TurnZero HQ logs your Commander games and gives every deck a real win-rate record, so you can tell whether that first commander is actually working for you.
Create Free Account