Gift Guide
Gifting a Magic: The Gathering player is easy to get wrong: generic merch nobody plays with, or a card that doesn't fit a single deck they own. Here are two lists, one for somebody just getting into Commander and one for a player who already has decks.
Start with one question: do they already have a Commander deck they play? If they don't, the first list is a deck that plays out of the box and the few things that go with it. If they do, the second list is the gifts that get used at every game night, and the best version of any of them is the one they asked for.
A preconstructed Commander deck is a complete 100-card deck that plays out of the box. The five Foundations Commander Decks (Calling All Angels, Keen Engineering, Reign of Dragons, Tramplesaurus Rex and Wretched Ranks) retail at $29.99, and each is a single color, which keeps a first deck simple to learn. Pick by what sounds fun to them: angels, Thopters, dragons, big trampling creatures or zombies. The precons page rates every deck if you want to compare.
A precon comes without sleeves or anything to track life and counters. The starter kit guide lists the few accessories a new player needs for a first game night, so the deck and the gear can be one gift.
Magic's Star Trek set releases November 13, 2026, with four Commander decks: Federation Fleet, Landing Party, Klingon Fury and We Are the Borg. For a Star Trek fan who already plays, one of those is the obvious pick, and Collector Boosters are the gift for someone who collects special printings. Before release, TCGplayer listings for the decks are well above what a Commander deck usually retails for, so it can pay to preorder from a local store or wait until after November 13.
Nothing beats a specific card for a deck they're actively building, but it only works if it's actually specific. Ask what they're missing, or check their decklist if they publish one: a TurnZero HQ deck page can show a Wishlist section right on it, naming exactly what the owner wants but doesn't own yet, which turns "what do I get them" into an actual shopping list instead of a guess.
Where to buy singles →A step up from generic accessories: sleeves or a deck box in a color that actually matches a deck they play. A friend of ours did this last year for a The Mycotyrant deck, in higher-quality sleeves than the recipient would have picked up for themselves. It reads as considered in a way a plain black or gray box never does, and it's a useful gift rather than one that sits on a shelf.
Best MTG sleeves → How to pick a deck box →Our own storage box for +1/+1 dials, status tokens and dice, sized to match a standard deck box. It's a strong individual gift for anyone still digging through a bag of loose dice, and it also works as a pooled gift from a playgroup that shares a table, since it's the kind of thing that ends up benefiting everyone at game night rather than one deck. If they already have one, a Dial Expansion pack (more +1/+1 dials for the same Cube) is the smaller, cheaper follow-up.
The Commander Cube → Shop the Cube on Etsy → Shop Dial Expansions on Etsy →Great for a player whose collection or deck count has outgrown its storage: a stack of color-sorted boxes for commons and uncommons, a real binder for the cards worth protecting, or a multi-deck case for someone carrying more than one build to game night. It's not a flashy gift, but it's one that gets used every single time they sit down to build or play.
How to manage a collection → Best collection tracker apps →As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra, and it does not change what is recommended here. See our affiliate disclosure.
A real carrier for someone hauling a full box of decks to game night, and something smaller for the nights that don't need the whole kit. We keep our main carrier for a full night out, but also picked up a small side satchel for the trips that only call for two decks and the Cube, which is most weeknight trips to the LGS. Worth asking which one they're actually missing before buying either.
MTG carrying cases on Amazon → Small deck satchels on Amazon → Multi-deck cases in full →For someone just starting, a Foundations Commander Deck with sleeves and a deck box. For a player who already has decks, a card from their wishlist, sleeves matched to a deck they love, the Commander Cube, or a Star Trek Commander Deck.
A preconstructed Commander deck. It's a complete 100-card deck that plays out of the box, and the five Foundations Commander Decks retail at $29.99 and are each a single color, which keeps a first deck simple to learn. Pair it with sleeves and a deck box and they have everything they need for a first game night.
Organization and carrying gear over cards. A quality deck box, storage boxes for a growing collection, or a bag built to actually carry decks all get used regardless of which colors or archetypes someone plays, unlike a card that might not fit a single deck they own.
Ask, or check their decklist if they publish one. If they use TurnZero HQ, their public deck page can show a Wishlist section listing exactly what they want but don't own yet, which turns guessing into a shopping list.
Yes, for a player who's tired of loose dice and tokens, and it works as a gift for an individual or as a pooled gift for a whole playgroup that shares a table. If they already have one, a Dial Expansion pack (more +1/+1 dials for the same box) is the smaller, cheaper follow-up gift.
It's one of the more thoughtful versions of this gift. Sleeves or a deck box in a color that matches a deck someone actually plays reads as considered rather than generic, especially compared to a plain black or gray box that could belong to anyone.
If they don't already have it, TurnZero HQ tracks their decks, games and collection for free on iOS, Android and the web.
Create Free Account